This year’s Lowy Institute Poll has recorded the lowest feelings of safety among Australians in our eleven-year polling history. In a tracking question first asked in 2005, fewer than one in four (24%) Australian adults say they feel ‘very safe’ in 2015, 18 points down from the 42% who felt very safe when we last asked the question in 2010.
The threat of terrorism appears to be the primary cause. From a list of eight potential risks to Australia’s security in the next ten years, risks relating to terrorism rank one, two, and three in Australians’ perceptions of risks to national security. The highest-ranked is ‘the emergence of Islamic State in Iraq and Syria’, with 69% of Australians rating this as a high risk to their security. ‘Terrorist attacks on Australians overseas’ and ‘home-grown terrorism in Australia’ rank second and third, with majorities (55% and 53% respectively) seeing these as high risk.
Risks of conflict in our region rank far lower in Australians’ threat perceptions. The possibility of ‘military conflict between the United States and China in Asia’ is the lowest-ranked of all eight risks, with only 20% seeing it as a high risk. Similarly, ‘maritime disputes between China and its neighbours in Asian territorial seas’ are seen as high risk by only 26% of the adult population. ‘A breakdown of law and order in Papua New Guinea’ (24% rating this ‘high risk’) and ‘potential epidemics such as the Ebola virus’ (22% saying ‘high risk’) rank sixth and seventh of the eight possible risks. In results consistent with our 2014 findings on potential threats to Australia’s vital interests, ‘a cyber attack on Australian critical infrastructure’ is ranked relatively highly as a risk (almost half — 45% — rating it a high risk). Younger Australians (18-29) are, however, far less wary of the cyber threat: only 26% see it as high risk, compared with 50% of those aged over 30.
With the threat of terrorism featuring prominently in public perceptions, the Government’s new data retention laws have the support of a clear majority of Australians. When asked about ‘legislation which will require Australian telecommunications companies to retain data about communications such as phone calls, emails and internet usage, but not their content’, 63% of Australians say this is ‘justified as part of the effort to combat terrorism and protect national security’. Only one-third (33%) say it ‘goes too far in violating citizens’ privacy and is therefore not justified’.
Support is even stronger among those who see the emergence of Islamic State in Iraq and Syria as a high risk: 70% of this subgroup (of all ages) say the policy is justified. Support is also strong among those who see the prospect of terrorist attacks on Australians overseas and home-grown terrorism as high risk (71% and 74% of these subgroups saying the policy is justified, respectively).
Younger Australians (aged 18-29) are more divided on the need for data retention, with almost equal numbers supporting and opposing the legislation (50% say it is justified, while 47% say it goes too far in violating citizens’ privacy).
As part of the international effort to combat Islamic State, the Australian Defence Force is currently participating in air strikes against Islamic State in Iraq, and providing training and support to Iraqi security forces. In polling conducted in April 2015 for the Lowy Institute by Newspoll, we found that most Australians support this military involvement despite their awareness of the potential risks.
The majority of the population (55%) believes that ‘Australia’s participation in military action against Islamic State in Iraq increases the risk of terrorism to Australia now’, although fewer (47%) say it ‘increases the risk of terrorism to Australia in the future’, and a small proportion (20%) say it ‘makes Australia safer from terrorism in the future.’
Yet despite fears of an increased risk of terrorism, the Australians who support air strikes against Islamic State and the provision of military assistance to Iraq far outnumber those who oppose it. A large majority (69%) are either strongly (36%) or somewhat (33%) in favour of this military participation. Only 22% say they are against such action.
After more than a year in office, the Coalition Government’s performance on its key policy platforms — turning back asylum seeker boats, improving the budget bottom line and reducing debt, and abolishing the carbon tax3 — appears to have left Australians unimpressed.
Asked to give the Coalition Government a mark out of ten for its handling of eight foreign policy issues (where ten means the government has done an ‘excellent job’, five an ‘average job’ and one ‘a very poor job’), Australian adults awarded the government a barely average mark for ‘handling the arrival of asylum seekers by boat’ (with a mean score of 4.9/10).
On ‘managing Australia’s economy’, the Coalition scored another marginal mark of 4.9/10, and it received a failing grade of 4.0/10 for ‘managing the issue of climate change’.
The Coalition’s marks were just above average for ‘promoting good relations with Asian nations’ (5.3/10) and ‘presenting a good image of Australia internationally’ (5.4/10).
Slightly higher marks were awarded for ‘responding to the threat of terrorism’ (5.9/10) and ‘representing Australia’s interests on the UN Security Council and the G20’ (6.0/10). The highest mark awarded was 7.1/10 for ‘maintaining a strong alliance with the United States’.
In a similar question asked in our 2010 Poll, Australians awarded the Rudd Labor Government two below-average scores (4.2 for handling asylum seekers and 3.9 for dealing with Japanese whaling), one average score (5.0 for ‘combating climate change’) and five above-average scores, with the highest mark of 7.2/10 given for its work in maintaining a strong US alliance.
Australians’ poor perceptions of the Coalition Government’s economic management have been accompanied by a sharp decline in optimism about the performance of the Australian economy in the world.
In the single largest fall in optimism recorded since 2005, 63% of Australians are optimistic (54%) or very optimistic (9%) about the nation’s ‘economic performance in the world over the next five years’. This is a 13-point fall since this question was last asked in 2013, and 23 points lower than the highs of 86% recorded in 2009 and 2010 at the height of the global economic crisis.
Australians have mixed views about free trade agreements such as those concluded in 2014 by the Coalition Government with Japan, Korea, and China. Less than a majority (48%) see them as good for the Australian economy, though fewer (30%) say they are bad for the economy. But regardless of the economic benefits, a solid majority (65%) say they are good for Australia’s relations with those countries.
The issue of foreign investment in Australian residential real estate has caused considerable public debate. In March 2015, during fieldwork for this Poll, the Australian Treasurer announced the forced sale of a Sydney home valued at around $40 million, purchased by a Hong Kong-based property group through an Australian company in apparent contravention of foreign investment rules.4 A week earlier, the government flagged new measures to enforce rules for foreign investment in Australian real estate, following a parliamentary inquiry in 2014.5
The 2015 Lowy Institute Poll asked Australians whether the Australian Government is allowing too much foreign investment in residential real estate from six countries and regions: China, Europe, Japan, the Middle East, Russia and the United States. A substantial majority of Australians responded that the Government allows too much investment from China (70%), followed by the Middle East (50% saying too much investment). Only minorities say the Government allows too much investment from Japan (47%), Russia (37%), the United States (34%) and Europe (34%).
Our historical polling suggests that Australians may have a particular aversion to Chinese investment in residential real estate compared with other forms of Chinese investment in Australia. Over the last five years (2010-2014), Lowy Institute polls found smaller majorities (between 56% and 57%) of the population who said that the Government allows too much investment from China.
In 2015, Australians continue to hold a mixed, perhaps even contradictory, set of views on China.
When asked whether China is ‘more of an economic partner to Australia or more of a military threat to Australia’, a solid majority (77%) see China as ‘more of an economic partner’. Only 15% see it as ‘more of a military threat’. Previous Lowy Institute polling has found that the majority of Australians see China as by far the most important economy to Australia, with 76% saying China was ‘the most important economy to Australia’ in 2013, ahead of both the United States and Japan (16% named the United States as our most important economy in 2013, and 5% named Japan).
Fears that China poses a military threat appear to have eased somewhat this year, with 39% of the population believing it likely that ‘China will become a military threat to Australia in the next 20 years’. In 2014, this was nine points higher at 48%.
In late 2013 and early 2014, tensions flared between China and Japan over their competing claims of sovereignty to the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands in the East China Sea.6 This year, we asked Australians their views on what Australia should do ‘in the event of a military conflict between China and Japan’. A very substantial 84% of Australians say ‘Australia should remain neutral’. A small minority (11%) say ‘Australia should support Japan’, while only 3% say ‘Australia should support China’.
Feelings in general towards China remain steady at a warmish 58° on the Lowy Institute ‘feelings thermometer’. While a majority of Australians (61%) still believe in 2015 that ‘China’s aim is to dominate Asia’, a larger majority (67%) agree with the more benign view that ‘China’s aim is to create a better life for the Chinese people’. A substantial proportion of the population (73%) agrees that ‘Australia should develop closer relations with China as it grows in influence’, and a majority (52%) now disagree that ‘Australia should join with other countries to limit China’s influence’, which was not the majority view in our 2008, 2010 and 2011 Polls (46%, 40% and 47% respectively).
Nevertheless, 66% of Australians this year say that ‘Australia should do more to resist China’s military aggression in our region, even if this affects our economic relationship’. In further evidence of this wariness of China’s increasing influence and assertiveness, a majority (56%) disagree that ‘having China as an important global power makes the world more stable’.
The 2015 Poll reaffirms Australians’ enduring support for our alliance with the United States. After a slight decline in support between 2012 and 2014, the vast majority (80%) in 2015 say that the US alliance is ‘very’ or ‘fairly’ important for Australia’s security, a majority (53%) seeing it as ‘very important’. This is 17 points higher than the low point in 2007 during the presidency of George W. Bush. Support for the alliance is strong regardless of gender or age.
In a question first asked in 2011 to better understand attitudes towards the alliance, we presented five different arguments this year and asked Australians whether they agreed or disagreed with each. Our 2015 results reinforce our findings in 2011 that the US alliance is seen as a natural extension of our shared values and ideals, while acknowledging that the alliance allows Australia to expend less on its defence. Most Australians (77%) agree that ‘Australians and Americans share many common values and ideals’, and see the alliance as a ‘natural extension of this’. A solid majority (70%) agree that ‘without the alliance, Australia would have to spend much more money on its defence’.
The fear expressed by the majority (73%) in 2011 that the alliance ‘makes it more likely that Australia will be drawn into a war in Asia that would not be in Australia’s interests’ has weakened significantly, only 58% agreeing this is a risk in 2015. This aligns with our findings (see page 5) that very few Australians rate the possibility of conflict in Asia between the United States and China or of maritime disputes between China and its neighbours as of high risk to our security. However, the alliance is seen as hedging against any threat from China, with the majority of Australians (53%) agreeing that ‘the alliance relationship with the United States makes Australia safer from attack or pressure from China’.
Most Australians reject the idea that the United States is in decline. Few Australians (37%, down from 41% in 2011) agree that the ‘United States is in decline relative to China, and so the alliance is of decreasing importance’. This argument finds strongest support among those aged 60 and over (47% agreeing, compared with only 33% of those under 60 years of age).
Although few Australians regard the United States as in decline relative to China, not many see its power increasing either. When asked about the role of the United States as a world leader in the future, only 10% say the United States ‘will play a more important and powerful role’, while 61% say it will play ‘about as important a role’. Around a quarter (27%) say it will play a less important role. Perhaps surprisingly, among young Australians, 15% of 18-29 year-olds say the United States will play a more important role as a world leader in ten years’ time, compared with only 8% of their elders.
The Australia-Indonesia relationship has been strained by the spying furor in late 2013, when allegations were made that Australia had listened in to telephone conversations of the Indonesian president, his wife and senior Indonesian officials.7 More recently, in April 2015, the executions of Australian citizens Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran for drug trafficking offences have created additional friction.
Australians’ feelings towards Indonesia have now fallen to their lowest point in eight years. Even before the executions of Chan and Sukumaran, Indonesia registered a cool 46° on the Lowy Institute thermometer of feelings towards other countries. The last, and only time, sentiments towards Indonesia were this low was in 2007, after a period of discord in relations following Schappelle Corby’s sentencing for drug offences and Australia’s granting of asylum to Papuans in 2006. Indonesia’s reading this year is eight points lower than the peaks of 54° in 2010, after the Australian visit of then president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, and again in 2012. This places Indonesia, in Australians’ eyes, on a par with Russia (45°) and Egypt (48°).8
The asylum seeker issue has also been a source of tension in the relationship. The vast majority of Australians (87%) believe that ‘Indonesia should do more to help Australia combat people smuggling’, while almost as many (85%) say that ‘Indonesia should do more to combat the risk of Islamic terrorism’. Most (65%) say that ‘Indonesia should abolish the death penalty’.9
A surprisingly high proportion (though a minority) of the population (42%) supports Australian navy vessels ‘entering Indonesian territorial waters without permission, as part of Australia’s efforts to turn back asylum seekers’. A slim majority (55%) disagree that such incursions are justified.
Australians value a personal approach to the relationship with Indonesia. A substantial majority (76%) of Australians agree that ‘Australian prime ministers should work harder to develop personal relationships with their Indonesian counterparts’.
Australians still seem to have a poor understanding of domestic developments in Indonesia. In 2015, only one-third (34%) of Australians regard Indonesia as a democracy, almost exactly the proportion who said this in 2013 (33%), despite the fact that Indonesia has been a parliamentary democracy for over fifteen years. After the ten-year presidency of Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, elections in 2014 saw Joko Widodo elected as the new president of Indonesia. Yet when asked about President Jokowi, 42% of Australians responded that they do not know him.
Lowy Institute polling both before and after the executions indicates a clear majority of Australians oppose the death penalty for drug trafficking. In separate polling in February 2015, we asked Australians about the (then) planned executions of Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran. Sixty-two per cent of Australians said that the executions should not proceed, and 69% said that the death penalty should not be used as a penalty for drug trafficking. In an almost identical result in supplementary polling in May after the executions, 71% opposed the death penalty for drug trafficking.
In the 2015 Lowy Institute Poll and again in our subsequent polling in May, we asked whether the ‘Australian Government should play an active role in the abolition of the death penalty internationally’, and how the government should respond if ‘an Australian is executed in another country as a result of a death penalty’. By a slight margin, more people (51%) say the government should play an active role in the abolition of the death penalty internationally than those who say it should not (45%), with this division fairly consistent across age groups and gender. Attitudes on this question before and after the executions were very consistent.
Australians’ strong preference, ‘if an Australian is executed in another country as a result of a death penalty’, is for the issue to be addressed by quiet diplomacy. In a question asked both in our 2015 Poll in February/March and again a few days after the executions of Chan and Sukumaran and following the recall of Australia’s ambassador to Jakarta in May, we asked Australians how the government should respond. The results for both polls were very similar. The only option gaining majority support is for the government to ‘make private diplomatic protests’ (59% in agreement in May). Only a minority (42% in May) agree that the government should recall Australia’s ambassador, and even then, most believe the period of disruption should be short: 51% nominated a period of ‘about one to four months only’ when asked for how long Australia should suspend normal diplomatic relations with Indonesia. There was scant support either before or after the executions for suspending Australian aid projects (28% agreeing in May) or suspending military and law enforcement cooperation (27%). The least supported action was for applying trade sanctions (24%).
The 2015 Poll has recorded the third consecutive rise in Australians’ concern about global warming. In a tracking question asked since 2006, half the adult population (50%, up 5 points since 2014 and 14 points since 2012) now say ‘global warming is a serious and pressing problem. We should begin taking steps now even if this involves significant costs’, though the number remains considerably lower than the peak of concern recorded in 2006 when 68% expressed this view. Only 1 in 8 (12%) say ‘until we are sure that global warming is really a problem, we should not take any steps that would have economic costs’.
In the lead-up to the 2015 UN climate change conference in Paris, we sought Australians’ views on the approach the Australian Government should take in international climate negotiations. A solid majority (63%) say ‘the Australian Government should commit to significant reductions so that other countries will be encouraged to do the same’, with significantly more women (70%) than men (56%) favouring this approach. Support is also stronger among 18-29 year-olds, with 70% advocating a significant commitment from government on emissions reductions. The opposing proposition, that ‘the Australian Government should not make significant commitments on emissions reductions ahead of other countries’ is accepted by only 35% of the population.
Australians have high expectations of the role solar energy will play in Australia’s future energy mix. When presented with seven possible sources of energy and asked ‘which one of these energy sources do you think will be our primary source of electricity ten years from now’, ‘solar energy’ is by far the highest-ranked option, with 43% of the adult population saying that this ‘will be our primary source of electricity 10 years from now’. By contrast, ‘coal’ is selected by only 17%.
Despite the fact that Australia currently has no nuclear power plants, a significant 13% of the population believes ‘nuclear energy’ will be our primary source of electricity 10 years from now, higher than for ‘natural gas’ (10%), ‘wind’ (7%), and ‘hydroelectric power’ (6%).
These expectations contrast starkly with Australia’s current energy-generation mix. Coal currently accounts for over 60% of Australia’s electricity generation, followed by gas at 21% and hydroelectricity at 7%. Solar energy accounts for less than 2% of electricity generation in Australia.10
Our 2015 polling suggests that few Australian adults see the government’s current aid budget as inadequate, despite the significant reductions to Australia’s overseas aid both in the 2014/15 and 2015/16 Budgets.11
In a short poll following this year’s May Budget, we found that a majority of Australians (53%) are in favour of the most recent reductions to overseas aid. While nearly one in five express strong opposition to the reductions (19% ‘strongly against’ the reductions), only 35% overall oppose the reductions. In our earlier 2015 Poll survey, only 21% said that Australia’s 2014-15 aid expenditure, at ‘5 billion dollars in aid to developing countries, or around 1.2 per cent of the Budget’ is ‘not enough’. On the contrary, 36% said this is ‘too much’, while 41% said it is ‘about the right amount’.
Younger Australians are far more inclined to be critical of the level of the aid budget. Among 18-29 year-olds, only 33% support the most recent budget cuts; 42% — still not a majority — oppose the cuts. 34% said the 2014/15 aid budget is ‘not enough’, compared with 17% of those aged over 30.
The largest recipient of Australian aid in 2015/16 will be our close neighbour and former colony Papua New Guinea (PNG), with an estimated aid expenditure of around $554m. Indonesia, our second largest aid recipient in 2015/16, will receive $366m. Australia is PNG’s largest aid donor.
In 2015, the year of the 40th anniversary of PNG’s independence, Australians seem to have a strong sense of obligation to PNG and some understanding of its importance to Australia. The vast majority (82%) agree that ‘stability in PNG is important to our national interest’, and 77% say ‘Australia has a moral obligation to help PNG’. Yet despite Australia’s significant aid program in PNG, Australians are divided on its impact: 38% agree that ‘Australian aid to PNG has little impact on life in PNG’, while 42% disagree, and a relatively high 20% say they either don’t know or have no view on the impact of Australian aid on life in PNG.
While PNG’s economy is forecast to be one of the world’s fastest-growing economies in 2015, only a minority of Australians (37%) agree that ‘PNG has strong economic prospects’.12
Australians aged over 45 appear to have stronger feelings about PNG: 90% agree that PNG’s stability is in our national interest, and 82% say that Australia has a moral obligation to help PNG.
Australians’ views on democracy, and particularly those of younger Australians, have been among the most striking findings of our last four years of polling. In 2015, 65% of the voting-age population say that ‘democracy is preferable to any other kind of government’ (up from between 59-60% over the preceding three years). There has been a corresponding drop (from 24% in 2014 to 18% this year) in the proportion of the population who believe that ‘in some circumstances, a non-democratic government can be preferable’.
As in past years, only a minority (49%) of 18-29 year-old Australians express a preference for democracy, although fewer this year see a non-democratic government as an alternative, with 23% (down 10 points) saying ‘in some circumstances, a non-democratic government can be preferable’. A quarter of this age group (26%) say ‘it doesn’t matter what kind of government we have’.
Every Lowy Institute Poll since 2005 has included our annual ‘feelings thermometer’, which measures Australians’ feelings towards a range of other countries on a scale of 0° in temperature (coldest feelings) to 100° (warmest feelings).
In 2015, Australians’ coldest rankings are given to North Korea (29°), Syria (33°, down 6 points since 2012) and Iraq (35°). Following the February 2015 release of Australian journalist Peter Greste after more than a year’s imprisonment in Egypt, Australians’ sentiments towards Egypt have cooled a significant 8 points from 2012 to a cool 48° this year.
At 46°, feelings towards Indonesia have fallen to their lowest point in eight years of polling. This puts Indonesia on the same level as Russia (45°, down 10° since last on our thermometer in 2010) and Egypt (48°).
Feelings towards our largest neighbours in the region are steady. Feelings towards China (58°), India (56°) and Malaysia (58°) are on the lukewarm side, while Japan at 68° is more warmly regarded.
Among our near neighbours in the Pacific, Papua New Guinea’s ranking remains lukewarm at 58°, having cooled over the last three years from a high of 64° in 2012. Fiji enjoys a warmer spot at 68°.
At a warm 73°, Australians’ feelings towards our security partner, the United States, have been warming steadily since their low point of 60° in 2007. Australians see the relationship between the two countries as one of firm friendship. In a short poll in 2014, when we asked Australians to choose ‘Australia’s best friend’ from a list of six countries in the world, the United States ranked highest with New Zealand (with 35% and 32% of the population respectively choosing them as ‘Australia’s best friend’), followed by the United Kingdom (17%) and China (9%). Japan and Indonesia were chosen by only 1% each.13
Australians’ warmth towards the United Kingdom has been a consistent feature of Lowy Institute polling, with the UK (Great Britain) scoring a very warm 79° in 2015. When asked about the relationship between Australia and the UK in our short 2014 poll, the vast majority (82%) saw it as an important relationship for Australia, two-thirds (67%) of whom ascribed that importance to the ‘strong historical and cultural ties between the two countries’. Only 26% said it is important because ‘the UK is still a major economic and strategic power’. The ‘great sporting rivalry between the two countries’ was seen by only 5% of Australians in 2014 as the reason they think the relationship between the UK and Australia is important.
This year, as on every other occasion it has been included, New Zealand tops the thermometer at a consistently warm 83°.
In 2015, we repeated a question first asked in 2014 seeking the views of Australians on a range of world leaders. This year’s list of ten leaders included four from the 2014 list: US President Barack Obama, former Secretary of State and now presidential candidate Hillary Clinton, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, and Chinese President Xi Jinping. Also included this year were the new Indonesian President Joko Widodo, PNG’s Prime Minister Peter O’Neill, Russian President Vladimir Putin, Japan’s Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, India’s new Prime Minister Narendra Modi, and the Pope.
The most admired leader this year is again Barack Obama, admired by 86% of Australians. Next comes Hillary Clinton (admired by 77%, though down 4 points this year). Pope Francis ranked third at 73%.
Last year, high proportions of Australians answered ‘don’t know’ in their responses about a number of leaders included in this question. This year, we adjusted the question slightly to divide those who ‘don’t know the person’ by name from those who have no view on them as leaders.
This year, Angela Merkel is admired by just under half the adult population (47%), but another 40% don’t know her, despite her well-publicised visit and speeches in Australia at the time of the G20 meetings in Brisbane.
More Australians ‘don’t admire’ Indonesian President Jokowi (29%) than ‘admire’ him (25%), though 42% don’t know of him.
PNG’s Prime Minister Peter O’Neill has a very low profile in Australia, with 61% of Australians saying they don’t know of him (while 24% say they admire him).
Last year, a very substantial 64% responded ‘don’t know’ when asked about their admiration for China’s President Xi Jinping. This year that number dropped to 58% (53% saying they don’t know of him), while 23% admire him and 19% don’t admire him.
There is a similar lack of knowledge in Australia about the Japanese and Indian leaders. Shinzo Abe is not known by 59% of Australians, and 66% don’t know of Narendra Modi, while they are each admired by around 20% of the population.
Australians are unequivocal in their lack of admiration for Vladimir Putin, who of all the leaders on the list attracted the highest proportion of Australians (67%) saying they ‘don’t admire’ him.
Finally, key elements of Australia’s multilateral diplomacy have the strong support of Australians. Australia held a temporary seat on the United Nations Security Council in 2013-14, and was President of the G20 in 2014.
In 2015, nearly two-thirds of the adult population (62%) say that the kind of role Australia played in the UN Security Council and as the host of the G20 leaders’ meetings in Brisbane was worth the effort and cost. Only a third (33%) regard it as not worth the effort and cost.