At a more macro level, however, evidence is beginning to emerge that the spigot is being tightened. Government Guidance Funds (GGFs), act as a type of venture capital fund for local governments and have deployed at least US$500 billion (Opens in new window). Data available (Opens in new window) for 2024 shows that the establishment of new GGFs fell by 32%, while pledged capital decreased by 37%.
As well as being driven by explicit fiscal pressures, the decline (Opens in new window) in GGF activity reflects attempts by the central government to better align funding with overall national priorities. Grants to SMEs and listed companies also registered noticeable declines in 2024.
Given fiscal constraints, Beijing is now leaning on capital markets and China’s vast banking system to marshal capital towards companies in priority sectors.
But the banking sector can only do so much. Pressure on banks to provide local governments and ailing SOEs with cheap capital has led to a collapse (Opens in new window) in net interest margins over the last decade.
Some China watchers think Beijing is counting (Opens in new window) on a massive increase in productivity and corporate profitability, which will ultimately replenish state coffers. Barring that or other increases to revenue like taxation, fiscal reality demands that China be increasingly judicious in its use of industrial policy.
Will the rest of the world get a meaningful reprieve?
Probably in some sectors, but the picture is far from clear cut.
Titans such as BYD, CATL and Huawei lead global innovation in their sectors. Subsidies help (Opens in new window), but are not necessarily the driving force behind their competitive advantage.
China’s sheer economies of scale, huge STEM workforce (Opens in new window), growing dominance (Opens in new window) of industrial supply chains and ability to vertically integrate will all continue to confer their own potent advantages.
Tighter constraints on industrial policy might also help rationalise sectors experiencing intense overcapacity, to the benefit of industry leaders.
Economies in the industrialised world would do better than to hope for China Inc to collapse under the weight of its own contradictions.