China’s weight is concentrated heavily in trade, investment, infrastructure and industrial supply chains. In defence, technology, education and maritime security, Indonesia’s relationships are distributed more widely across the United States, Australia, Japan, South Korea and European partners. No single country can replace China across all these areas, just as China cannot replace every other partner in the functions they perform.
The objective should not be to find one power that balances another everywhere. It should be to ensure that dependence in one sector does not become leverage across the entire relationship. That is the logic of strategic redundancy.
The asymmetry is clearest in economics. Lowy Institute’s Southeast Asia Influence Index (Opens in new window) gives China a score of 91.7 for its economic relationship with Indonesia, more than twice Singapore’s 41.0, and well ahead of Japan, South Korea and the United States.
Security looks different. The same index ranks the United States as Indonesia’s leading defence partner, followed by Singapore, the Philippines and Australia. The 2025 Asia Power Index (Opens in new window) captures the broader imbalance: Indonesia ranks fifth in Asia for diplomatic influence, but 11th for economic relationships and 12th for defence networks.
Diplomatic diversification does not automatically produce material depth. That difference is easy to miss when every new agreement is announced as strategic. Jakarta can maintain relations with China, the United States, Russia, Japan, Australia and others while remaining highly dependent on one partner for a particular economic or technological function.
Strategic redundancy offers a better way to think about autonomy. It does not require Indonesia to duplicate every partnership or minimise relations with major powers. It requires Jakarta to preserve more than one viable option in sectors where dependence can become political leverage.
In defence procurement, that means avoiding excessive reliance on a single supplier for critical platforms, maintenance or ammunition. In critical minerals, it means ensuring that investment, processing technology and export markets are not concentrated in one external relationship. The same logic applies to digital infrastructure and energy.